yòng háishi tíwèn
Choice questions with 还是 (用"还是"提问)
Use 还是 between two options to force a choice: 'A or B?' The listener must pick one. This is different from 或者 (or), which is used in statements, not questions.
核心例句
你坐地铁还是打车?地铁快,打车贵——你选哪个?
Nǐ zuò dìtiě háishi dǎchē? Dìtiě kuài, dǎchē guì — nǐ xuǎn nǎge?
Are you taking the subway or a taxi? The subway is faster, a taxi is pricier — which do you choose?
HSK 1
HSK 1
1
1 个结构
10
10 个练习
课程摘要
Use 还是 between two options to force a choice: 'A or B?' The listener must pick one. This is different from 或者 (or), which is used in statements, not questions.
**What it means:** 还是 creates a choice question — it presents exactly two options and asks the listener to select one. This is different from an open-ended question.
**Structure:** A + 还是 + B? - A and B can be nouns: 苹果还是橙子? - A and B can be verb phrases: 你去学校还是待在家? - A and B can be full clauses sharing the same subject.
**When to use:** Use 还是 when you have two clear alternatives and want the listener to choose one. It implies that one or the other must be true.
**When NOT to use:** - NEVER add 吗 to a 还是 question: 你去还是不去吗?is WRONG. - Do NOT use 还是 in a statement (use 或者 instead): 你可以喝茶或者咖啡。(statement) vs. 你喝茶还是咖啡?(question)
**Common mistake — 还是 vs 或者:** - 还是: questions only, forces a choice between two things. - 或者: statements only, means 'or' when listing options without asking. - WRONG in a statement: 你喝茶还是咖啡就好。 → use 或者 - WRONG in a question: 你喝茶或者咖啡? → use 还是
**Answering a 还是 question:** Choose one option — do NOT answer with 是 or 不是.
语法句型
A or B? (forced choice)
还是 connects two options in a question. The listener must choose one of the two.
你坐地铁还是打车?
Nǐ zuò dìtiě háishi dǎchē?
Are you taking the subway or a taxi?
你在家吃还是出去吃?
Nǐ zài jiā chī háishi chūqù chī?
Are you eating at home or going out to eat?
今天星期一还是星期二?
Jīntiān xīngqīyī háishi xīngqīèr?
Is today Monday or Tuesday?
填写空白: